By Your Side
Through It All
Reach Out Today
Women calculating tax on settlement

Will I Be Taxed on My Personal Injury Settlement?

Denning Law Firm, LLC May 2, 2024

After enduring the stress and turmoil of a personal injury, receiving a settlement can provide significant financial relief. However, many wonder if this silver lining has a cloud in the form of taxes.

The simple answer is reassuringly positive for most: the IRS does not typically tax personal injury settlements. This policy is designed to ensure that victims are not penalized for receiving compensation for their injuries. However, certain exceptions apply, making it imperative to understand the specifics of your settlement. 

IRS and State Taxes After Receiving Compensation  

The tax burden on a personal injury settlement hinges on the nature of the damages you receive. Understanding how the IRS views your compensation is essential. The taxability of a settlement typically revolves around three types of damages: actual, emotional distress, and punitive.  

Actual Damages Resulting From Physical or Non-Physical Injury  

If your settlement encompasses compensation for actual costs incurred as a result of an injury, these amounts are typically not taxable. The rationale lies in the ‘compensation for loss’ principle, which means the funds received are restorative in nature, aligning with the tax-free status of money used to recover from losses.  

These damages include: 

  • Medical Expenses: Immediate medical expenses are generally seen as reimbursing a loss, which is not considered income. 

  • Lost Income: Money to replace income you could not earn due to the injury is typically tax-exempt, but we strongly encourage concerned parties to consult with a tax professional. 

  • Property Damage: Reimbursement for repair or replacement of damaged property is non-taxable. 

Emotional Distress Damages Arising From the Actual Injury  

The taxability of emotional damages hinges on their relationship to the physical injury. If your settlement includes compensation for emotional distress directly related to a physical injury, it is non-taxable. However, if your settlement concerns emotional distress without a physical trigger, it may be considered taxable income.  

To reiterate, emotional distress may be taxable depending on whether it stems from physical harm or an independent claim: 

  • Physical Harm: Emotional distress linked to a tangible injury is generally non-taxable. 

  • Independent Emotional Distress Claims: Emotional distress claims independent of physical harm may be subject to taxation. 

Punitive Damages  

In personal injury cases, punitive damages are awarded to the plaintiff to punish the defendant for reckless or harmful behavior. Unlike compensatory damages, punitive damages are typically taxable because they do not fall under the restorative principle. The IRS views punitive damages as additional income that is not intended to compensate for a loss. 

From an IRS standpoint:  

  • Additional Income: Punitive damages are generally considered windfall gains and are usually taxable. 

  • Exceptions: In certain cases, punitive damages for certain injuries or deaths may be tax-free. 

Exceptions to the Rule 

While the above framework is a strong guide, exceptions exist, and it's important to consult with a tax professional to ensure your understanding is current and accurate. Some notable exceptions pertain to specific injuries or settlements with unusual structures. For instance, there are certain legal settlements, like the Black Lung Benefits Act, that are explicitly spelled out as exempt by the IRS.  

Some of these exceptions include: 

  • Statutory Exemptions: Some settling variations under specific laws may be non-taxable. 

  • Explosives-related Injuries: Under certain contexts, the IRS exempts punitive damages for personal physical injuries. 

How Your Attorney Can Assist With Taxation on Your Settlement 

Having a knowledgeable attorney by your side is crucial to understanding how your personal injury settlement could be taxed. Here's how legal counsel can assist: 

  • Understanding the Tax Implications: An attorney can help decipher the specific details of your settlement and how they align with current tax laws, ensuring you understand potential tax implications. 

  • Structured Settlements: Your attorney can guide you in structuring your settlement to maximize tax benefits. For example, by receiving payments over time (structured settlement) rather than a lump sum, you may reduce your tax liability. 

  • Distinguishing Between Taxable and Non-Taxable Damages: A seasoned attorney can effectively argue for a settlement structure that maximizes the non-taxable portion of your compensation (e.g., physical injuries compensation) and minimizes the taxable portion (e.g., punitive damages). 

  • Negotiating With the IRS: If there are any disputes or unclear tax liabilities, your attorney can negotiate with the IRS on your behalf, providing necessary documentation and arguments to support the tax-exempt status of your settlement. 

  • Advising on State Tax Laws: Besides federal taxes, your attorney can also advise on potential state tax obligations, which can vary significantly from one state to another. 

  • Documentation and Reporting: They will ensure that you have the correct documentation and help with reporting the settlement on your tax returns if necessary, reducing the likelihood of future disputes with the IRS. 

In summary, the right attorney will not only advocate for your best interests during the settlement process but also ensure that you receive your compensation with the most favorable tax considerations in mind. 

Understand Your Rights  

The tax impact of a personal injury settlement is not a one-size-fits-all scenario. The details of your settlement agreement greatly affect whether or not you will need to pay taxes on it. By staying informed, consulting with tax professionals, and understanding the nuances of IRS and state tax laws, you can feel confident that you won't face unexpected tax liabilities on your personal injury settlement.  

In working with a seasoned legal team at Denning Law Firm, LLC, you will gain the insights necessary to maximize your settlement's non-taxable components while minimizing your tax exposure. Our goal is to get the settlement you deserve and to ensure that you are well-equipped to manage the legal and financial implications that follow. Serving those in the Kansas City, Missouri, area—including Overland Park, Leawood, Shawnee, Lenexa, and Olathe, Kansas—get in touch with us today for support.